Yves Saint Laurent Y vs Azzaro Silver Black
Partial matchAzzaro Silver Black shares part of Yves Saint Laurent Y's profile. Treat it as the same family rather than a stand-in.
They share 8 of Yves Saint Laurent Y's 11 main accords: aromatic, woody, fresh spicy and warm spicy.
Azzaro Silver Black costs about 23% of the price, around €41 against €175.
Azzaro Silver Black sits closer to the skin.
What you give up: ginger, sage and juniper berries, which Azzaro Silver Black does not list.


Main accords
Both
AromaticWoodyFresh spicyWarm spicyFruityFreshCitrusGreen
Only Y
AmberGourmandHerbal
Only Azzaro Silver Black
MuskyPatchouli
Notes
Both
AppleBergamotVetiver
Only Y
GingerSageJuniper BerriesGeraniumAmberwoodTonka BeanCedarOlibanum
Only Azzaro Silver Black
LimeAniseJuniperCorianderCardamomPatchouliWhite MuskSandalwood
Longevity and sillage
Y
Longevity75%
Sillage70%
Azzaro Silver Black
Longevity75%
Sillage45%