Head to head

Yves Saint Laurent Y vs Azzaro Silver Black

Partial match

Azzaro Silver Black shares part of Yves Saint Laurent Y's profile. Treat it as the same family rather than a stand-in.

They share 8 of Yves Saint Laurent Y's 11 main accords: aromatic, woody, fresh spicy and warm spicy.

Azzaro Silver Black costs about 23% of the price, around €41 against €175.

Azzaro Silver Black sits closer to the skin.

What you give up: ginger, sage and juniper berries, which Azzaro Silver Black does not list.

Yves Saint Laurent Y

The original

Yves Saint Laurent

Y

Eau de Parfum, 2018

€175

Buy at Amazon
Azzaro Silver Black

The alternative

Azzaro

Azzaro Silver Black

Eau de Toilette, 2005

€41

Main accords

Both

AromaticWoodyFresh spicyWarm spicyFruityFreshCitrusGreen

Only Y

AmberGourmandHerbal

Only Azzaro Silver Black

MuskyPatchouli

Notes

Both

AppleBergamotVetiver

Only Y

GingerSageJuniper BerriesGeraniumAmberwoodTonka BeanCedarOlibanum

Only Azzaro Silver Black

LimeAniseJuniperCorianderCardamomPatchouliWhite MuskSandalwood

Longevity and sillage

Y

Longevity75%
Sillage70%

Azzaro Silver Black

Longevity75%
Sillage45%
Every cheaper alternative to YY: full profileAzzaro Silver Black: full profileHow we judge a match