Head to head

Kilian Intoxicated vs Carolina Herrera 212 Vip Black I Love Ny

Near match

Carolina Herrera 212 Vip Black I Love Ny has most of Kilian Intoxicated's accords, but not at the same strength, so it reads as a near match rather than a copy.

They share 5 of Kilian Intoxicated's 6 main accords: warm spicy, gourmand, coffee and fresh spicy.

Carolina Herrera 212 Vip Black I Love Ny costs about 46% of the price, around €145 against €315.

Carolina Herrera 212 Vip Black I Love Ny sits closer to the skin.

What you give up: bergamot, aldehydes and nutmeg, which Carolina Herrera 212 Vip Black I Love Ny does not list.

Kilian Intoxicated

The original

Kilian

Kilian Intoxicated

Eau de Parfum, 2014

€315

Buy at Amazon
Carolina Herrera 212 Vip Black I Love Ny

The alternative

Carolina Herrera

212 Vip Black I Love Ny

Eau de Parfum, 2023

€145

Buy at Amazon

Main accords

Both

Warm spicyGourmandCoffeeFresh spicyAromatic

Only Kilian Intoxicated

Cinnamon

Only 212 Vip Black I Love Ny

LavenderCitrus

Notes

Both

CardamomCoffee

Only Kilian Intoxicated

BergamotAldehydesNutmegCinnamonGingerTobaccoGeraniumCaramelMochaVanillaCoumarinMarshmallow

Only 212 Vip Black I Love Ny

GrapefruitLavenderAbsintheVetiver

Longevity and sillage

Kilian Intoxicated

Longevity75%
Sillage70%

212 Vip Black I Love Ny

Longevity75%
Sillage45%
Every cheaper alternative to Kilian IntoxicatedKilian Intoxicated: full profile212 Vip Black I Love Ny: full profileHow we judge a match